home *** CD-ROM | disk | FTP | other *** search
- <text id=89TT0983>
- <title>
- Apr. 10, 1989: The Place Of The Skull
- </title>
- <history>
- TIME--The Weekly Newsmagazine--1989
- Apr. 10, 1989 The New USSR
- </history>
- <article>
- <source>Time Magazine</source>
- <hdr>
- BOOKS, Page 120
- THE PLACE OF THE SKULL
- </hdr>
- <body>
- <p>One of Gorbachev's favorite authors, Chingiz Aitmatov, offers
- a violent portrait of drug runners and nature-hating
- bureaucrats in his latest novel. Cast as a morality drama of
- Dostoyevskian power, Aitmatov's tale can also be read as a
- literary reflection of Gorbachev's reforms
- </p>
- <p>By Chingiz Aitmatov
- </p>
- <p> Few novels have caused as much of a stir in Mikhail
- Gorbachev's Soviet Union as The Place of the Skull, by Chingiz
- Aitmatov. Set in Soviet Central Asia, it is primarily the story
- of Avdiy Kallistratov, a journalist who infiltrates a gang of
- anasha (marijuana) smugglers. An ex-seminarian, Avdiy repeatedly
- attempts to convert drug runners and wildlife predators to God
- until he meets his own calvary in the Moyun-Kum steppes of
- Kazakhstan.
- </p>
- <p> The Place of the Skull is a searing attack on drugs, the
- destruction of wildlife, the stupidity of Communist Party
- officials in the countryside. But on a deeper level the novel
- is a metaphysical reflection on the confrontation between good
- and evil, infused with the magical realism that dominates the
- works of such novelists as Gabriel Garcia Marquez and Salman
- Rushdie.
- </p>
- <p> When the literary monthly Novy Mir published the novel in
- two installments in 1986, the magazine's print run of 427,000
- sold out immediately, and millions of copies of the book have
- been sold in the Soviet Union. Translated into English, The
- Place of the Skull will be published later this month in the
- U.S. (Grove; $20.95). A native of the Soviet Asian republic of
- Kirghizia, Aitmatov, 60, is one of his country's best-known
- writers. His most famous fan: Gorbachev, who says he has read
- nearly every word Aitmatov has written.
- </p>
- <p> In the first excerpt, Avdiy has just been thrown off a
- train by drug smugglers. Left to die in a railway ditch, Avdiy
- conjures up the conversation between Jesus Christ and Pontius
- Pilate shortly before the Crucifixion. In the second excerpt,
- Avdiy undergoes his own crucifixion. Taken together, the scenes
- create an allegory not only of good vs. evil but also of state
- power vs. the individual.
- </p>
- <p> IT WAS A HOT morning in Jerusalem, promising an even hotter
- day. On the Arched Terrace of Herod's palace, beneath the
- marbled colonnade where Pontius Pilate had ordered his seat to
- be placed, a gentle breeze blew from below to cool the sandaled
- feet. The tops of the triangular poplars in the great garden
- rustled quietly, their leaves prematurely yellowed in the
- dryness of this year.
- </p>
- <p> From the Arched Terrace perched on this stony mount, there
- was a view of the whole city, shimmering in the heat. The city
- boundaries, always clearly demarcated, seemed today to merge
- into the border of the white desert beyond.
- </p>
- <p> That morning, a single bird circled high above the great
- garden, wings spread wide, passing in regular sweeps as though
- swinging like a pendulum suspended from the heavens. It had to
- be an eagle or a hawk, since no other bird would have the
- patience to circle so slowly or so long through the furnace of
- the sky. When he noticed Jesus of Nazareth, who stood shifting
- his weight before him, glance upward at the bird, the Procurator
- was indignant and even offended at the glance. He spoke
- irritably and harshly: "Why look up, King of the Jews? That's
- your death circling above!"
- </p>
- <p> "Death circles above us all," answered Jesus quietly,
- automatically putting his hand to the dust-stained bruise on
- his eye. As they led him to the judgment of the Sanhedrin, he
- had been attacked by a crowd whipped up by the priests and
- elders. Had they forgotten how they had once shouted as he rode
- in through the city gates on the gray she-ass with her colt
- running behind, how they acclaimed him in hope and threw flowers
- beneath the hooves of the ass? "Hosanna to the Son of David!
- Hosanna in the highest!"
- </p>
- <p> Now he stood frowning, his clothes torn, before Pontius
- Pilate, waiting for whatever might happen next.
- </p>
- <p> The Procurator was badly out of sorts and mainly, strangely
- enough, with himself, with the sluggish way his mind was
- working and with his inability to accept a decision. Such a
- thing had never happened to him before, either during his time
- as an active soldier in the Roman army or during his tour of
- duty as a Procurator. Laughable! Instead of giving his immediate
- approval to the sentence passed by the Sanhedrin and cutting
- down his work load, he was dragging out the interrogation. It
- would have been so simple to summon the Chief Priest and his
- retinue, who were waiting for his call, and say, "Here you are.
- Take your prisoner, and do with him what you have decided." And
- yet something prevented Pontius Pilate from taking this simple
- step. Was this fool worth taking trouble over?
- </p>
- <p> "What do you really mean by `bringing the words of your
- Father to the people'? You mean making fools of them, getting
- the ignorant masses over to your side! Perhaps you should be
- bringing His word to me as well? I'm a person, too, you know!"
- </p>
- <p> "You, Roman Governor, have no need of it as yet, for you do
- not suffer or thirst for another kind of life. For you, there
- is nothing higher."
- </p>
- <p> "Right. There is nothing higher than the power of Rome. I
- hope that is what you meant to say?"
- </p>
- <p> "That is what you think, Governor."
- </p>
- <p> "That is what clever men have always thought," Pilate
- corrected him condescendingly. "That is why they say that Caesar
- is not a god, but God is like Caesar. Convince me that it is not
- so, if you are so sure of yourself. Are you sure that Caesar is
- less than God?"
- </p>
- <p> "He is mortal."
- </p>
- <p> "Obviously. But while he is alive and well, is there God
- above Caesar for men?"
- </p>
- <p> "There is, Roman Governor, if you choose another dimension
- of being."
- </p>
- <p> "Enough!" cried the Procurator. "We're wasting our time."
- </p>
- <p> Pontius Pilate gives Jesus one last chance to recant, but
- he refuses, explaining why he is prepared to die for what he
- believes in. "Let us talk like free men," said Pilate. "I am in
- no way dependent on you, and you, as you understand, are on the
- threshold of complete freedom, so let's be frank. Did you tell
- your disciples that if you were crucified, you would rise again
- on the third day, and once arisen, would come back to earth for
- a Last Judgment of those who are alive today, and those who are
- yet to be born, of all generations since the creation of the
- world? What of the Last Judgment?"
- </p>
- <p> "Has it not struck you, Roman ruler, that it has long since
- commenced for us?"
- </p>
- <p> "Are you trying to say that the whole of our life is one
- Last Judgment?"
- </p>
- <p> "You're not far from the truth. Since our first parents
- were driven from the Garden of Eden, what a pit of evil has
- yawned beneath us, what wars, cruelty, murders, persecutions,
- injustice and humiliation the human race has known! And all the
- terrible sins against goodness, against nature committed on this
- earth since the world began, what are they, if not a punishment
- far greater than the Last Judgment? Is not the purpose of
- history to draw thinking creation closer to the divine heights
- of love and sympathy? Instead of drawing closer, however, many
- lives have been broken in the course of human history, with no
- end in sight to the evil that surges up on every side like waves
- in the ocean. Is not life in this hell worse than any Last
- Judgment?"
- </p>
- <p> "Well, Jesus of Nazareth, I have listened most carefully to
- all you had to say. Do you not have too much hope in human
- faith, forgetting how fickle and venal they are out there in the
- streets and the squares? One thing puzzles me: Why are you
- lighting a fire in which you yourself will be the first to
- perish? Without the Caesars, human society could not exist. It
- needs the power and majesty of the few and the subjugation of
- the many. That is why, in the name of Tiberius, I rule over the
- Jews. This is my role in life, and my conscience is at peace.
- There is no greater honor than to serve all-conquering Rome!"
- </p>
- <p> "You are no exception, Roman Governor. Almost every man
- thirsts for power over at least one fellow creature. That is
- man's misfortune. Nations will perish in the struggle for power
- and land. They will tear each other up by the roots and
- eradicate each other in the struggle."
- </p>
- <p> "Stop! I am not one of your pupils. He who is strongest
- seizes power, and the strongest will always rule the world. This
- rule is as firm as the stars in the sky. It is useless to care
- for the human race, and useless for you to want to save it at
- the price of your own life. Men will always follow the Caesars
- as the sheep follow their shepherds and, bowing to strength and
- privilege, will respect the one who proves himself most
- merciless and most powerful. Reflect on your illusions and
- mistakes at least now, when the hour has come for you to go
- under guard to the Place of the Skull. You see the root of all
- evil in men's love of power, in subjugating lands and people by
- force, but by doing so you are only compounding your guilt in
- the eyes of the authorities, for he who is against power is
- also, de facto, against those who exercise that power. You wish
- to hinder the growing power of Rome, to prevent its taking
- control of all the world. Just to want such a thing is enough
- to condemn you three times over!"
- </p>
- <p> The Procurator pulled himself up to his full height beneath
- the arches of the terrace and stood there, tall and
- broad-browed, with big features and a firm stare, in his
- snow-white toga.
- </p>
- <p> "Just one more time, for the record," he said. "Father:
- What do you say his name was? Joseph. Mother: Mary. From
- Nazareth. Thirty-three years old. Unmarried. No children.
- Incited the people to revolt. Threatened to destroy the great
- Temple at Jerusalem and rebuild it within three days. Made
- himself out to be a prophet, the King of the Jews. There's the
- story of your life in a nutshell."
- </p>
- <p> "Never mind the story of my life. One thing I will tell
- you, though, Pontius Pilate, is that yours will find a place in
- history," said Jesus the Nazarene quietly, with a direct,
- serious look into the Procurator's eyes. "Forever."
- </p>
- <p> Pontius Pilate brushed the suggestion aside, flattered,
- however, by the notion. Suddenly he changed his tone and
- announced triumphantly, "It's our glorious Emperor Tiberius who
- will live forever in history. Glory to his name! We are merely
- his faithful outriders, nothing more."
- </p>
- <p> "You know, you really will find a place in history, Pontius
- Pilate," he repeated stubbornly, the man who was setting off
- for the Place of the Skull, beyond the city walls...
- </p>
- <p> Avdiy awakes from his dream and eventually is enlisted into
- helping local authorities boost their meat-production figures
- by massacring herds of antelope. Assigned to a five-man team led
- by the savagely cruel Ober Kandalov, who seems to be Aitmatov's
- stand-in for Stalin, Avdiy is so appalled by the slaughter that
- he implores the hunters to stop and turn to God. A drunken
- Kandalov orders his men to beat Avdiy. Then, enthroned on a
- crate, he gives Avdiy one more chance to recant. "SO, YOU
- BASTARD, thought you'd frighten us with your God, did you?
- Wanted to ram your God down our throats, you slime! You won't
- frighten us with God; you chose the wrong congregation this
- time, you filth.
- </p>
- <p> "We're carrying out an official government assignment,
- fulfilling the plan, and you're trying to implement economic
- sabotage. You're a bastard, an enemy of the people, an enemy of
- the people and the state. There's no room for enemies, wreckers
- and saboteurs like you! It was Stalin who said, `He who is not
- with us is against us.' Enemies of the people should be rooted
- out and destroyed! And you, you church rat, what have you been
- doing? Sowing subversion! You wanted to take us for a ride, all
- the way to the front door of the church perhaps, eh? I could
- strangle you, you runt, as an enemy of the people, and I would
- be thanked for it, seeing as you're an imperialist agent, you
- snake! I'm your higher authority now, so you renounce your God
- or it'll be curtains for you, you pig!"
- </p>
- <p> Avdiy could not stay up on his knees and fell to the
- ground. They lifted him up.
- </p>
- <p> "Answer me, snake," roared Ober Kandalov. "Renounce your
- God! Say there's no God!"
- </p>
- <p> "There is a God," groaned Avdiy weakly.
- </p>
- <p> "So that's the way it is!" screeched Mishash. "Like I said,
- you tell the bastard one thing, and he answers just the
- opposite!"
- </p>
- <p> Breathless with anger, Kandalov shook Avdiy again by the
- scruff of his neck.
- </p>
- <p> "Let me tell you something, God lover, we're going to put
- on a little show for you that you'll remember all the rest of
- your days! Haul him over to that tree there, hang him up, hang
- the bastard up!" They hauled Avdiy over to a gnarled saxaul
- tree spreading its branches at the edge of the hollow.
- </p>
- <p> "Bring the rope!" shouted Ober.
- </p>
- <p> Their thuggish horseplay was taking an ominous turn. A
- stupid practical joke now threatened to turn into a real
- lynching. "There's only one problem, dammit, no cross and nails
- in this stinking steppe! A real crying shame!" grumbled Mishash,
- noisily cracking off twigs of the saxaul. "That would have been
- the thing, to crucify the bastard!"
- </p>
- <p> "What the hell, we'll tie him on with ropes! It'll be as
- good as any nails!" proposed Ober. "We'll stretch him out by the
- arms and legs like a frog and lash him so tight he can't even
- twitch! Let him hang there till morning, and then he'll learn
- what's what! I taught worse than him to dance to my tune in the
- army! Hang him up on that branch over there, the high one! Twist
- his arm over the top branch and his leg under the bottom one!"
- </p>
- <p> The deed was done, and Avdiy was incapable of any
- resistance. Lashed to the gnarled saxaul tree, bound hand and
- foot with ropes, he dangled like a cured skin hung out to dry.
- Avdiy could still hear his tormentors cursing, but as if from
- a distance. There was a shooting pain in his abdomen, and his
- back felt as if some ligament had been snapped or torn, so
- agonizingly did it hurt.
- </p>
- <p> The look of him, something between a scarecrow and a
- gibbet, amused them all no end. Ober was particularly inspired.
- He had visions of far more impressive and extensive spectacles;
- why stop at one rat hanging there in the middle of the steppe?
- </p>
- <p> "That's what I'd do with the lot of them, like it or lump
- it, and don't you forget it!" he threatened, staring up at
- Avdiy. "I'd string them all up, everyone who's against us, not
- like this but so's they'd croak right away. Hang the lot of
- them, and leave them hanging in a long line all around the
- world, circling it like a hoop, then no one would ever dare
- oppose a single word we said, and they'd all dance to our tune.
- Come on now, Commissars, let's have another! What the hell, we
- only live once!"
- </p>
- <p> The final flood of human life was moving in. Before Avdiy's
- fading eyes there was a vision of water, an infinite,
- uninterrupted expanse without beginning and without end. The
- water seethed soundlessly, and silent white waves rolled across
- its surface, like a snowstorm over a field. On the very edge of
- that soundless sea he could just make out the figure of a man,
- and Avdiy recognized him: it was his father, Deacon
- Kallistratov. Then Avdiy heard his own voice, speaking as a boy,
- repeating to his father his favorite prayer about a sunken ship,
- just as he had repeated it so often at home in his childhood,
- standing beside the old piano. Only now the distance between
- them was immense, and he heard his father's voice ringing with
- inspiration, reverberating across the surface of the earth:
- </p>
- <p> "I ask but for one thing, one miracle. As long as night
- follows day and day follows night in the way ordained by You for
- our earth, as it spins through the empty wastes of space, as
- long as the spray beats salty into the air and the seagulls cry,
- may the ship hold its course for the radiant city on the distant
- ocean shore, though none may cast anchor there in all the eons
- of time. Amen."
- </p>
- <p> All night long, the silence of the boundless Moyun-Kum
- savanna was flooded with bright, blinding moonlight,
- illuminating the stiffened figure of a man crucified on a saxaul
- tree. The figure was like a large bird with outspread wings,
- struck down as it soared heavenward and blown into the branches.
- </p>
-
- </body>
- </article>
- </text>
-
-